Disruptive Thinking

Chapter 15 of Disruptive Thinking is entitled The Power of Talk. Beers and Probst discuss the difference between in monologic and dialogic questions. Monologic questions have a right or best answer. They require the student to pay attention to the text. They remind me of closed questions - questions that you answer with a yes, no, and/or a fact. Dialogic questions have no easy answer. They entertain discussion. Students don't know the answer question because there is no correct answer. In addition, they require the student to look for evidence to support their answer. They also automatically compel the student to answer the question in a complete sentence. To me, they remind me of an open ended question. Questions like what surprised me about the text? What did the author think I already know? What challenged my thinking from reading the text? Did reading this text change my mind/opinion?

Comments

The Reading Strategies Book Using The Radius of Us by Marie Marquardt

On a different no As I progress through The Reading Strategies book by Jennifer Serravalino, I stumble through new and familiar strategies. Strategy 5.4 is the good old plot map. I added it to my sketch notes, in order to turn my sketch notes into a one pager. Depending on the reader, this is an activity that be done as the reader progresses through the book, or at the end of the reading. In the past, I have asked students to pick the five most important events only. After, students can write a summary of the book if required. On a different note, at one of our professional developments, Penny Kittle spoke. She briefed over thematic notebooks, in which students write to the theme based off the book they are reading. Because books hold various themes throughout them, students can write to theme prompts reading a singular book. (At least this is my understanding). I created several theme notebooks to practice this. I try to just ...

Book Reviw: The Radius of Us

The Radius of Us by Marie Marquardt is about Gretchen and Phoenix. Both have experienced extreme trauma resulting in mental health issues that plague them and prevent them from moving forward in life. Despite Phoenix inadvertently triggering a panic attach in Gretchen, they come together and support one another as they battle through extreme anxiety and halting guilt. What I loved about the book was that the author, Marie Marquardt, is an active member at El Refugio - a non profit that serves detained immigrants. When she tells Phoenix's story as he makes his way out of El Salvador with his younger brother, and awaits the US Courts decisions about remaining in the US, it is authentic. She knows the stories of people like Phoenix and writes his story with compassion and empathy. What I did not understand was why Gretchen seeks out Phoenix, after fleeing from him when he appears out of nowhere at the park. Not only does she take off with her litt...

Reading Strategies Book Using The Maid by Nita Prose

What's Your Problem: Strategy 5.8 Problem: Molly is accused of the murder of Mr. Black. The Grand Regency Hotel is where Molly works. It is where Mr. Black dies, and where she interacts with people on a daily basis. Molly is on the autistic spectrum. Because the way her brain works, she has difficulty reading social cues. In the past, her Gran would help her, but since her passing she does not have anyone to help navigate and interpret the events that are going on around her. As a result, when she is questioned by the police regarding discovering Mr. Black's body. Though she is truthful, she is not forthcoming about all she has seen and heard. In addition, because she is lonely and wants to fit in, she misinterprets other's actions, and therefore trusts the wrong people. Theme: Prejudice Most people think of prejudice as a race or a culture thing. But prejudice also occurs against people who go go against the grain, that functi...

Mrs. HP Teacher Librarian!

Search This Blog